5 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla

Welcome to a gastronomic paradise! Anguilla, a Caribbean gem renowned for its stunning beaches and tranquil ambiance, also boasts an exquisite culinary scene that will delight even the most discerning food lovers.

From toes-in-the-sand beachfront eateries to elegant fine-dining establishments, this tiny island offers a diverse array of delectable delights that celebrate local flavors and international cuisines alike.

Whether you’re a fresh seafood enthusiast, a connoisseur of Caribbean spices, or someone with a passion for global tastes, my handpicked selection of the best places to eat in Anguilla is sure to elevate your dining experience to new heights.

Get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey through the island’s culinary wonders!

best places to eat in Anguilla

Where is Anguilla?

In my recent adventure, I was invited by the Anguilla Tourist Board to spend three unforgettable days in Anguilla, a British overseas territory nestled in the Eastern Caribbean, just a short 20-minute ferry ride north from Sint Maarten and to the east of Puerto Rico.

Read our post on 22 Things You May Not Know About Anguilla.

Where is the best place to stay in Anguilla?

In my experience, if you are spending your vacation on a luxury island like Anguilla, go all out and stay in a luxury hotel, such as the Viceroy or CuisinArt Golf Resort & Spa.

If you are looking for something more budget-friendly, I spent a few nights at Anguilla Great House Beach Resort, which has an amazing location, directly on the beach, but the rooms could use a renovation.

I also spent a night at Anacaona Boutique Resort. This one is not on the beach but does have access to two beautiful pools.


What is Anguilla’s famous dish?

Anguilla’s National Dish is Pigeon Peas and Rice. You can find my 5 best restaurants below.

Does Anguilla have a beach bar?

In Anguilla, the beach bar is a way of life. With sunny days and warm nights, open-air bars abound.

Try the Elvis Beach Bar. This casual watering hole is located at Sandy Ground on Road Bay. The bar is constructed from the hull of a traditional Anguillian sailboat, snugged in the sand beneath a corrugated tin roof sheltering rafters festooned with a wardrobe of baseball caps and T-shirts.

Featured on the TravelChannel and rated the best Caribbean beach bar by USA Today in 2022, Elvis’ is a must-do Anguilla beach bar.

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla

What is the best month to visit Anguilla?

The best times to visit Anguilla are February through April when rain is at its lowest. The worst times to visit are August through December when it rains the most.

What are the best things to do in Anguilla?

Your Caribbean island stay is most likely to revolve around water, sunbaking, and eating.

You’re going to want to make a list of places to visit including Shoal Bay, Rendezvous Bay, Bay East, Shoal Bay East, Island Harbour, Crocus Bay, and Maundays Bay. Just for a start.

These are the worst things you could do in Anguilla.

Check out these cool activities from Get Your Guide.


5 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla

The Restaurant – Sandy Island

Address: 6V7J+2PJ, Sandy Ground, The Valley 2640, Anguilla

Get ready for the ultimate foodie adventure because we’ve got a secret culinary spot that’s out of this world! Imagine dining on your very own private island, just a quick speedboat shuttle away from the main island of Anguilla.

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla

Fresh, flavorful, and fantastically good – that’s what you can expect from the cuisine here! Everything is prepared right on the island, so you know you’re in for a treat with every bite.


I indulged in a mouthwatering chicken and salad plate that had my taste buds doing the happy dance. Maybe it was the mesmerizing views, or perhaps it was the heavenly cuisine, but honestly, how can any meal be anything less than amazing when you’re feasting on your own mini-island in the Caribbean? It’s a dining experience that will leave you floating on cloud nine!

This is the place to have your Anguilla crayfish or grilled lobster!



Address: 6W2C+M6V, Reverend Carty Road, Sandy Ground, Anguilla

Hold on to your taste buds because this place is the place to be when the sun goes down! The perfect dinner spot.

Picture this: we sauntered in and were instantly swept off our feet by toe-tapping live music, the over-the-top décor that screamed “fabulous,” and the staff who seemed to sprinkle magic wherever they went.

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla - Veya

But wait, there’s more – the real star of the show was the cuisine, straight from the Big Apple! We’re talking about impeccable bites crafted by a culinary genius from New York City.


Straw Hat

Address: John Hodge Rd, Meads Bay 2640, Anguilla

Hold your hats, folks, because the Straw Hat restaurant is taking things to a whole new level of awesomeness! I kid you not, this place is not your run-of-the-mill eatery.

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla - Straw Hat

From the moment you step in, you’re in for a wild ride of themed wonders! Straw-hat lights illuminating the way, bread served up in, you guessed it, a straw hat, and guess what? You can even strut out of there with your very own stylish straw hat!

Now, if that’s not a recipe for quirky fun, I don’t know what is! But hey, it’s not all just about the hats – this joint sits right on the edge of the Caribbean Sea at Meads Bay Beach, serving up scrumptious delights that’ll make your taste buds do the happy hula.

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla

Prepare to feast on delicious food while basking in the vibrant and lively atmosphere that’s sure to put a big ol’ grin on your face. It’s the kind of place where food and fun unite to create memories you’ll treasure forever!



UPDATE: Unfortunately this Anguilla restaurant is permanently closed

We’ve got ourselves a beachside delight that’s going to make your taste buds sing and your heart does a happy dance! Say hello to the ultimate lunch spot that’s got it all – sand, sun, and scrumptiousness!

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla

Grab a table right there on the sandy shores, kick off your shoes, and let the beach vibes wash over you like a wave of pure bliss. This place is a paradise for families! While the kiddos are busy conquering the waves and building epic sandcastles, you can savor your cocktail in a moment of pure tranquility.

But what about the food? Brace yourself for a flavor explosion! My jerk chicken wrap was a fiery fiesta for the taste buds, a bit more than I could handle, but those fresh fish bite appetizers are an absolute showstopper.



Address: Barnes Bay, The Valley 2640, Anguilla

Get ready to glam up and bring your A-game, because we’re talking about beachside fine dining that’s going to make you feel like a superstar! No sandy toes here, folks – it’s your chance to rock those fancy threads and hit the town with your special someone.

 Best Places To Eat In Anguilla - Mango's

You’re going to be enjoying a dreamy evening, with the ocean breeze whispering sweet nothings, and indulging in some serious top-notch eats on this part of the island.

My steak might not have sent me straight to the moon, but let me tell you, it still brought a whole lot of flavor to the party! So, if you’re in the mood to wine, dine, and shine, this is the place to be, where the beach meets sophistication.


Ah, the Caribbean – where culinary delights come with a dash of splurge! Get ready to treat yourself, because these dining experiences might make your purse feel a little lighter, but trust me, your taste buds will be dancing in delight!

Freshness is the key ingredient in every dish, and that’s worth every penny. But hey, fear not, you’ll be saving money on costly attractions because a dive into the sparkling warm waters of the Caribbean doesn’t cost a cent.




FOMO - do you have it?  Well there is no need to Fear On Missing Out here at Explore With Erin. Sign up to receive updates directly to your in box. I won’t spam you, but I do promise a whole lot of awesomeness. What are you waiting for? Join Me!

PS: We hate spam too, read our Privacy Policy here.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Start typing and press Enter to search